Using binary silver labels in electronic health records-based computable phenotyping algorithms

Shuhe Wang, Matthew T. Slaughter, Jennifer C. Nelson, Brian D. Williamson

Gold-standard phenotype labels are often unavailable at scale in electronic health record (EHR) studies because they require manual chart review. Weakly supervised phenotyping methods instead use silver-standard labels, such as diagnosis-code counts, natural language processing (NLP) mentions, medication indicators, or laboratory thresholds. PheNorm is widely used for this purpose, but its original formulation was designed for count-valued silver labels and relies on log transformation, utilization normalization, and Gaussian mixture modeling. These steps are not directly suited to binary silver labels, which are common and may be highly informative. We propose Binary PheNorm, an extension that uses binary silver labels directly in the corruption-and-regression denoising step and produces a continuous phenotype score without EM calibration. We also consider a lasso-regularized version for high-dimensional EHR settings and combined models using both binary and count labels. In simulations, Binary PheNorm achieved strong discrimination using binary labels alone and often improved performance when combined with count labels. In anaphylaxis, AUC increased from 0.793 for an epinephrine-mention indicator to 0.891-0.892 after Binary PheNorm. In acute pancreatitis, AUC increased from 0.736 for a lipase-threshold indicator to 0.805-0.819. These results support Binary PheNorm as a practical weakly supervised approach when informative binary silver labels are available.