Joint Chance Constrained Safe-Optimal Control

Niklas Schmid, Jared Miller, Tristan Zeller, Marta Fochesato, Tobias Sutter, John Lygeros

We consider the finite-time optimal control of stochastic systems subject to a probabilistic constraint on the trajectories' safety. Such formulations are known as joint chance constrained optimal control problems. The common practice is to jointly minimise the expected cost of all trajectories, safe and unsafe. This leads to policies which invite constraint violations to exploit low-cost unsafe trajectories. When constraints represent states of critical failure, such behaviour is undesirable. We demonstrate that this behaviour can be overcome by only minimizing the expected cost of safe trajectories. The underlying rationale follows a practical intuition: In many applications, the cost incurred by unsafe trajectories is irrelevant (e.g., the battery usage of a crashed quadcopter), and one is usually interested in minimizing the cost of trajectories that are safe. We show that this problem can be cast as a constrained Markov Decision Process over an augmented state space. This allows solving it via dynamic programming. We derive bounds on the policies' safety under errors resulting from gridding approximations when the system's state space is continuous. Finally, we empirically compare dynamic programming as well as reinforcement learning solutions on a simulated 2D unicycle system in cluttered reach-avoid environments.